CriticizingThe Greatest Showman for its historical accuracy is missing the point of the movie, which never advertised itself as anything but an escapist fantasy with a killer soundtrack and a visually lush design. (He literally had Benihana as one of these restaurants and, as far as I know, they only hire Asian people. | Why Jeremy Jordan Sang For Hugh Jackman During Greatest Showman Demo, Why Critics Hated The Greatest Showman (And Why They're Wrong), Nightmare Alley Proves The Greatest Showman Got It Wrong, Greatest Showman True Story: Biggest Changes To The Real P. T. Barnum. Barnum as a mythological figure instead of a historical one, using his life as a framing device to tell a story about inclusion and acceptance. Jeremy Michael Jordan (born November 20, 1984) is an American actor and singer. The . Brilliant! (Yes, I literally spent HUNDREDS of dollars to change a flight and rush home early from a weekend wedding to do a four-minute appearance on a local news show. As hard as it was to get the first film made, talk ofThe Greatest Showman 2has been stirring for a few years, mainly from the main cast themselves. Just, logistically, how was there possibly time for that manor estate, with a finished garden and working light fixtures, to have deteriorated into a haunted house. Jeremy Jordan - The DataLounge When was Lighters Up by Lil Kim released? Barnum's songs, despite being a talented singer himself. In 2019 Jordan started appearing in the musical Waitress on Broadway alongside Shoshana Bean. Why The Greatest Showman's 'Never Enough' Singer - CINEMABLEND Spoiler alert, the role was eventually played by Zac Efron. Ah. Lind was uncomfortable with how relentless and tacky Barnum's marketing of her was, and so she split with him and then continued the tour on her own, for nearly a year. Giving incredible early tveit energy, but even more charisma. [17] Newsies opened at the Nederlander Theatre on March 29, 2012. [5] His stepmother died in a car crash when he was in 7th grade. I love a good movie musical. After the immense popularity ofThe Greatest Showman, there's been talk about whether a sequel could be in the works but should it kowtow to critical consensus? and our If she had to pick a favorite horror movie it would probably be The Shining but Ari Asters Hereditary and Midsommar rank in joint second place. I think Moulin Rouge! Perfect! Heres the song: Jeremy talked about how he really wanted to play Jamie in the film version of The Last Five Years and they asked him to audition with the song If I Didnt Believe In You. Then the feedback was they werent sure if he was funny. He enlisted Charles Stratton, or "General Tom Thumb" when he was 4. Like did he need to go to the bathroom? November 11, 2022, By Thats right. "Never Enough" requires a massive vocal range and belt . From 2015 to 2021, he played Winslow "Winn" Schott Jr. on the CBS/CW DC Comics-based superhero drama series Supergirl. [14] The show closed on December 30, 2011, after 36 performances. [26] In April 2021, he gave an interview on The Theatre Podcast with Alan Seales,[27] discussing his 54/Below cabaret show "Carry On". Natch. Shes obsessed with dogs too so any films from the sad dog movie genre (Homeward Bound, Marley & Me, etc) make her ugly cry big time but shes still a cold-hearted horror movie fan, ok? NY 10036. Not everything needs to be about you! And just look into his eyes. So, in The Greatest Showman, an immigrant who started from nothing and went on to publish the . He performs a great deal of the music as part of the clip that's available (check it out, it's all pretty good) and he absolutely would have killed it. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Trang Dong on Twitter [8], Jordan sang as a teenager and began acting in high school. Full Executive Team candidate list revealed for NTSU elections 2023 The soundtrack was a huge hit as well. ", "Guy Talk With Jeremy Jordan! By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. While critics condemned the movie musical for this,The Greatest Showman was never marketed as a legitimate reckoning with the legacy of P.T. As great a basketball player Jordan was, it's well known that he's a jerk. But, within five minutes, my optimism soured into distaste and general confusion. Phillip Carlyle and Anne Wheeler never . He has performed on Broadway, in television and film, in concert, as well as in other theatrical productions. He's best known for his roles in Smash (2012) & Supergirl (2015). You will receive a verification email shortly. [20][21] In December 2013, Jordan appeared in Hit List, a concert presentation of the fictional musical created for the second season of Smash. Jordan continues And he sang the goddamn damn song and it was beautiful and astonishing and very moving. It was delicious. His voice is easily recognisable for its unique tonal quality and remarkable power. [22] On February 16, 2015, Jordan starred as Leo Frank, opposite Laura Benanti as Lucille Frank, in the concert production of Parade, also written by Jason Robert Brown, at the Lincoln Center's Avery Fisher Hall. Jeremy Jordan. Barnum is the living embodiment of "for the fans, not the critics.". The songs ofThe Greatest Showman were engineered for sing-alongsand were successful across demographics something most musicals never achieve. Why was Jeremy Jordan not in greatest showman? Despite not being able to sing for producers, Jackman ultimately did have to go back to the doctor's to get restitched afterthe Greatest Showmandemo because he ended up breaking orders. 7 Retweets 56 . As a result, Jordan sang all of Jackmans songs as well as those for the Carlyle character. In December 2009, he left the show to play Tony in West. Seth Rudetsky In the movie, P.T. Well, maybe people were onto him because no one was hiring. Premiering in the midst of prestige TV and on the same weekend as the darker and more controversialStar Wars: The Last Jedi,The Greatest Showman's underdog storywas a candy-coated, family-friendly escape. On June 20, 2019, it was reported that Jordan would be starring as Casablanca Records founder Neil Bogart in the upcoming biopic Spinning Gold. Come on. Thus, it had to happen regardless of Jackman being sidelined as a singer. Her song is a jam, sure, but it's like an Adele song by way of one of those songs they used to write for whoever won American Idol. Films: "The Last 5 Years" opposite Anna Kendrick, "Joyful Noise" with Queen Latifah and Dolly Parton, "Newsies.". He starred in the Warner Bros. film Joyful Noise, opposite Queen Latifah, Keke Palmer, and Dolly Parton. Jordan married Broadway actress and singer Ashley Spencer on September 8, 2012. Really? The MCUs tiniest heroes are kicking off its biggest phase yet, setting up the next several years of storytelling. He surprises his wife with all of that information. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Barnum buys a massive mansion that he and his wife used to play in as children and yet again, it is a complete surprise. But he still leaves me cold. This film calls her the Swedish Nightingale. The biggest criticism ofThe Greatest Showman was that it whitewashed P.T. He has performed on Broadway, in television and film, as well as in other theatrical productions. The Greatest Showman is an original musical inspired by the life of P.T. January 24, 2023, By At the run-through, "Newsies" star Jeremy Jordan did the singing for Jackman while the actor mimed the stage directions. He nodded his head when his grandson asked if he was happy they were seeing the film. Criticism included that it didn't cover the true story of Barnum's circus in a fulfilling way and that it was shallow and watered down. 11 questions we had about The Greatest Showman - EW.com | Barnum, attempting to dispel the obvious hoax. And yet there is no reveal while Carlyle (who is a completely fictional character) is signing the paperwork or something, that his middle name is "Bailey." For the role, Jordan was nominated for the 2012 Tony Award for Best Performance by a Leading Actor in a Musical. In the performance, Jeremy Jordan revealed he felt he was being quite impressive, but then during the rendition of the films last song From Now On, something happened, And suddenly theres a bustling next to me. Supergirls Jeremy Jordan Recalls The Brutal Time He Performed The Greatest Showman With Hugh Jackman Before Losing Role To Zac Efron. Nothing in their relationship ever implies they ever did anything, let alone make major financial decisions together, and so staking the emotional climax of the film on that line made me full-on choke on my popcorn. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. The viral behind the scenes video he references can be seen here if somehow you haven't already come across it. In researching The Greatest Showman true story, we discovered that Barnum's eager young protg in the film, Phillip Carlyle (Zac Efron), is a fictional character. Barnum's story and his controversial history in favor of an inclusive message and broader appeal - a criticism that has also been leveled atHamilton since its release on Disney+. Privacy Policy. The Greatest Showman was directed by Michael Gracey and stars Academy Award-nominee Hugh Jackman alongside Academy Award-nominee Michelle Williams, Zendaya, Zac Efron, and Rebecca Ferguson. @JeremyMJordan @f_w_live @sarahcharness 1 10 60 Why did they get rid of Winn in Supergirl? Released a mere few months after the closure of Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus, "The Greatest Showman" told a fictionalized rendition of the life of one of its figureheads, the late P.T . Barnum's songs, despite being a talented singer himself. Why Did Jeremy Jordan Sing Naked on a Broadway Stage? The standout is "This Is Me," an anthem to diversity led by bearded lady Lettie Lutz (Keala Settle). Concerned that if he burst into song, he would split his stitches, cause. Another major financial decision they absolutely did not do together? Even the harshest critics of the movie were willing to admit that the songs, written by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul, whowere also songwriters forDear Evan Hansen and La La Land, were catchy earworms. Seth Rudetsky Although the primary criticism of The Greatest Showman 's music was about its saccharine styling and eclectic mix of genres, the album was successful because of just that. As a result, Jordan sang all of Jackman's songs as well as those for the Carlyle character. 45,826 listeners. No. Barnum biopic to the big screen. He'll star as Casablanca Records founder Neil Bogart in the upcoming feature, Spinning Gold. Barnum into a sympathetic figure, by the time I sunk into my seat, I was begrudgingly excited. He has performed at 54 Below in New York City many times as both a soloist and with his Smash costars. Instead, it succeeds because it achieves exactly what it set out to do: provide a glossy and fantastical escape from reality, set to a buoyant soundtrack that's impossible to not sing along with. Although the primary criticism of The Greatest Showman's music was about its saccharine styling and eclectic mix of genres, the album was successful because of just that. Honestly, hats off to you, Barnum. A key element critics did not enjoy was that the serious story of P.T. But not before hearing somebody whisper that Hugh had just met with Zac Efron about the part of Phillip. WOWZA! Jeremy Jordan sang for almost the entirety of The Greatest Showman demo since Jackman couldn't lend his own voice at that time (casting was also not yet finalized for the film). American actor, Jeremy Jordan sings 'From Now On' from hit Movie The Greatest Showman Then he sent me this. Shes produced content for the likes of Culture Trip, WhatCulture and Prague.TV and started writing for Screen Rant in 2019 firstly as a news writer before progressing onto writing mini-features. Review | Jeremy Jordan in Concert, Cadogan Hall Jeremy sang it a cappella and, after the last note, the guy told him to show up Thursday at 4 to start training. How did a hundred years pass for ivy to overgrow over the entire building? She married a German Jew, Otto Goldschmidt, and went by Jenny Lind-Goldschmidt both privately and professionally for the rest of her life. People enteredbut it wasnt the actors, it was more crew. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. He made his Broadway debut in 2009 as part of Rock of Ages. The Music. My first guest was Jeremy Jordan and it was the first time weve done a full show together. Honestly that's true. And he starts singing. Plus, all the drama that followed Seth and James on their latest cruisefrom disastrous doggie digestion to performer passport panic! I'm not the only one who mentally launched into a Pitbull song during "Rewrite the Stars," right? Critics hatedThe Greatest Showman when it was released in 2017, but the film's overwhelming word-of-mouth success and undeniably catchy soundtrack made the P.T. He sang the song Bonnie from the Broadway show Bonnie and Clyde (he played Clyde), which the character sang in a bathtub, naked. Barnum - a visionary who rose from nothing to create a mesmerizing spectacle that became a worldwide sensation. Hugh Jackman was there, but having recently had minor surgery on his nose, was told by his doctor not to sing. The Greatest Showmandemo was used to sell the idea of Jackman's passion project, but he was unable to sing P.T. Although this news excited some, it saddened those who had gone to see the circus as children. Jordan announced via social media that he would be starting a band, Age of Madness, which released their first album in spring 2022. Seth Rudetsky Barnum many of the darkest parts of which were elided was watered down with saccharine pop music, doubled by the choice to score a period movie to a pop soundtrack. That was Bennett's most notable involvement with P.T. It was helped by its optimistic message about literally pulling yourself up by your bootstraps and facing the snobby, wealthy villains; opening while its American audience was facing historic income inequality meant that everyone could identify as P.T. The film was released on February 20, 2021.[37]]. Please refresh the page and try again. While the movie did cop many bad reviews, it was a huge commercial success through word of mouth and many devoted fans. I think he ultimately wasn't the right choice for Dr. Pomatter but here he kills us with emotion. Ana De Armas Reflects On Blonde Backlash Ahead Of The Oscars, Disney's Haunted Mansion Reboot Looks Like The Studio's Return To Gateway Horror, And It's About Time, Are The Perfect Match Winners Still Together? Yay! However, the success of Broadway musicals likeDear Evan Hansen orHamilton, which proved that musicals can break into mainstream culture and be hugely successful, made the accessibility ofThe Greatest Showman a strength, rather than a weakness. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Related: Why Critics Hated The Greatest Showman (And Why They're Wrong), The Greatest Showman was a longtime passion project for Hugh Jackman and the actor spent the best part of a decade trying to bring the P.T. Huh. That's the climax of an episode of Hannah Montana. The Greatest Showman (2017) questions and answers - Moviemistakes With Help From Jeremy Jordan, Hugh Jackman Proves Why He Is the Ignoring all of that is one thing, but the worst crime this film does against Jenny is her voice. if we want to talk about a glow down it's going to be Zac Efron being casted in the Greatest Showman despite Jeremy Jordan having paid for his own plane ticket to sing for . Why Did Jeremy Jordan Sing Naked on a Broadway Stage? Whether that was what convinced Fox to go ahead with the film is unknown but director Michael Gracey certainly seems to think so, calling it a euphoric moment that helpedThe Greatest Showmangetmade. Copyright 1991-2023 Playbill Inc. All Rights Reserved. But after his father died, Barnum is living on the street. Did Hugh Jackman and Zac Efron sing in The Greatest Showman? I have the Into the Woods soundtrack on my phone. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Jordanwas an ideal choice to understudy for Jackman since he's starred in several musicals including Newsies,Bonnie & Clyde,andThe Last Five Years. So if there's going to be a sequel, and I'm not going to be on a Zimmer frame, we better get going." He ha read more. The movie's subplot about a curmudgeonly critic who hates Barnum's circus for not being serious theater almost winks at the critics, and makes it clear thatThe Greatest Showman is determined to be a broad, escapist movie about the expression of joy. Of course, none of this means that a sequel toThe Greatest Showmanis actually happening, butJackman and Williams are still hopeful. Naturally, he dropped Ashley and hightailed it home. Devoted fans of the movie credit that escapism as part of their love for it. why was jeremy jordan not in the greatest showman why was jeremy jordan not in the greatest showman Home Realizacje i porady Bez kategorii why was jeremy jordan not in the greatest showman. All in all, The Greatest Showman is P.T. His parents divorced when he was young, and he lived in low-income housing, with his brother, Joey, sister, Jessa, and mother, Debbie (ne Stone). Brava to not changing your life for a callback! Speaking of which, Robin de Jesus texted me because he was at the gym and listening to the brilliant Lillias White on the Actors Fund Dreamgirls concert cast recording that I produced. He graduated from Ithaca College w/ a degree musical theater in 2007. Even after Jackman got his film breakthrough playing Wolverine in the X-Men franchise, he stayed true to his musical theater roots, taking roles in productions of Carousel and The Boy From Oz. [32] In 2015, Jordan was cast as Winslow "Winn" Schott Jr. on Supergirl. 20th Century Fox's The Greatest Showman is a bold and original musical that tells the story of P.T. Barnum, Jordan was excited to learn of the role of Philip Carlyle as it was potentially a role he could play. From the 93 concerts she gave in America, Lind earned about $350,000, or what would be nearly $10 million today, and she donated all of the proceeds to charity. UmbreHonest 2 yr. ago I lovedddd him as Pomatter! which earned him a Laurence Olivier Award. The Greatest Showman was an incredible movie in a lot of ways. Anyhoo, we first talked about his move to NYC after college and his attempt to get a waitering gig. The Executive Officer roles are full-time, paid roles that suit people graduating or taking a year out from study at the end of the current academic year. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics". The 30-year-old actor while promoting The Greatest Showman with his 21-year-old co-star Zendaya was asked about his long history of movie kisses. Offers may be subject to change without notice. Why was the "Swedish Nightingale" an alto? Copyright 2023 Meredith Corporation. Supergirl's Jeremy Jordan Recalls The Brutal Time He Performed The Greatest Showman With Hugh Jackman Before Losing Role To Zac Efron. [10] Later that year, he played Tom Sawyer in Big River at the Goodspeed Opera House in Connecticut. Did Hugh Jackman Really Sing In The Greatest Showman? - Looper.com Why is Jeremy Jordan in the demo video with the cast of The Greatest Did Zendaya do the stunts in The Greatest Showman? Next time dont ask to audition with a song thats one of the most serious in the film! He went back, sang the comedic Shiksa Goddess, and did a great jobbut he knew there were still doubts about him. He has a new vocal coach so is singing in rounder, less harsh tones now. Chris told him to stop moving. Jeremy said yes. Jeremy said yes. I cant! What are the key features of the Limon technique? These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. Later, Jeremy Jordan was asked to fly to New York to perform the music for potential investors. Helen loves a good movie musical too and has probably watched The Rocky Horror Picture Show, Hedwig And The Angry Inch, The Blues Brothers and Little Shop Of Horrors more times than is healthy. Okay, but hold up. It was captured in a behind-the-scenes video you can check out below. The Greatest Showman follows the true story of P.T. Afterwards, he landed his 1st role on Broadway in Rock of Ages. [15], Jordan played Jack in the stage version of Newsies at the Paper Mill Playhouse in New Jersey in September and October 2011. The Greatest Showman demo was used to sell the idea of Jackman's passion project, but he was unable to sing P.T. Hugh Jackman was instrumental in gettingThe Greatest Showman made, becoming attached to the project in 2009 and championing its production until the 2017 premiere. You can see his projection comes from the diaphragm now and he's not scratching and screeching from his throat as much as before. And the word restaurants is in quotes is because he told us that he researched restaurants in his hometown of Corpus Christie and only wrote down ones that had closed! And suddenly theres a bustling next to me. Hugh Jackman might have described The Greatest Showman best when he described Barnums circus as enough to bring joy to the most joyless critic.. "The notes were gone, it was just air I was devastated," he recalls before moving on to talk about From Now On.. Jordan continues: "We get to the big 11 o'clock number, From Now On.It started out low and builds but not to a point that I couldn't reach in my current state. "[7] He was an excellent student,[5] graduating from Mary Carroll High School, where he was active in choir. He's already done the work, he needs to be given the rewards. Critics lampooned the movie for failing to live up to expectations thatThe Greatest Showmanmusical never set. October 28, 2022, By He graduated from Ithaca College, in Ithaca, New York, with a Bachelor of Fine Arts in musical theatre. And then gone. 13. December 29, 2022, By Jeremy Michael Jordan (born November 20, 1984) is an American stage actor and singer. jeremy-jordan.com - Events | Facebook Answer: There were other people in the circus who were just normal but had amazing abilities. On screen, he starred opposite Anna Kendrick in the 2014 musical film The Last Five Years and as Jimmy Collins in the NBC series Smash (2013). 17 Did Zendaya do the acrobatics in The Greatest Showman? Watch! He most recently starred on Broadway opposite Kerry Washington in the provocative new play, American Son, reprising his role in the recent Netflix film adaptation. Chris said that the audience wont know what hes feeling if they cant see his eyes. This isn't Jeremy's personal page, it's an extension of his website. This is complete fiction, as there is no evidence that the two ever had a romantic relationship. Jeremy Jordan was previously set to join the cast of the Off-Broadway revival of Little Shop of Horrors in the lead role of Seymour. Jeremy Jordan exited Supergirl at the end of season 3 due to a desire to spend more time with his family and explore new opportunities as an actor. By ", "Supergirl: Jeremy Jordan Shifts to Recurring Status in Season 4", "Jeremy Jordan to Play Casablanca Records Founder Neil Bogart in Spinning Gold", "Hallmark orders 40 new Christmas movies for 2020", "Jeremy Jordan on Instagram: "Happy 8 years to the most beautiful goofball I know. January 13, 2023, By The film opened on January 13, 2012. Future Club 33 Member. Greatest Showman 2 Updates: Sequel Release Date & Stageshow Details, Why Jeremy Jordan Sang For Hugh Jackman During Greatest Showman Demo, The Greatest Showman: How The LGBTQ Community Rescued It From Mediocrity, Michael Douglas Has Super Blunt Response to Possible Ant-Man 4 Return, Why Obi-Wan Didnt Use Force Speed To Save Qui-Gon Jinn From Darth Maul. Unfortunately, the day before everybody was set to meet for theGreatest Showmandemo, HughJackman had surgery on his nose to remove skin cancer which required 80 stitches and came with a strict doctors order not to sing. We already sat through this entire movie. Uno, do', tres, cuatro." When Jordan started singing The Greatest Showmansendingmusical number, "From Now On," Jackmanseemingly felt soinspired and moved by the song that he couldnt help himself and started singing along to the power ballad. Video: Go Inside Rehearsal for CAMELOT on Broadway. [12] He also starred as Clyde Barrow in the 2010 pre-Broadway Sarasota, Florida, tryout of the new musical Bonnie & Clyde by Frank Wildhorn and Don Black. Why Critics Hated The Greatest Showman (And Why They're Wrong) - ScreenRant We wound up singing You And Me But Mostly Me, the duet from Book of Mormon that almost happened for him. and seeing Jeremy Jordan that happy . Did Zendaya do the acrobatics in The Greatest Showman? The only time it's even obliquely referenced is when the protestors use a racial slur to describe members of Barnum's troupe. If you don't already have tix then I suggest you get one, you won't regret it Full interview to come. However, while Jackman obeyed his doctors orders for the majority of The Greatest Showman demo, one song got the better of him. [38][39] They have a daughter, Clara Eloise Jordan, born April 21, 2019. Williams told Variety thatshe hopes a sequel toThe Greatest Showman gets made because "I would make another one of those in a heartbeat." Jeremy Jordan was born on November 20, 1984 in Corpus Christi, Texas as Jeremy Michael Jordan. Here's What Georgia Hassarati And Dom Gabriel Say About Their Relationship After The Finale, Will Walker: Independence Return For Season 2 Amid CW Shakeups? These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. Among the historical figures this movie bulldozes in order to make room for a heroic P.T. Please consider supporting us bywhitelisting playbill.com with your ad blocker.Thank you! Jeremy Jordan was previously set to join the cast of the Off-Broadway revival of Little Shop of Horrors in the lead role of Seymour. Related:Nightmare Alley Proves The Greatest Showman Got It Wrong. Jeremy Jordan sang for almost the entirety of The Greatest Showman demo since Jackman couldnt lend his own voice at that time (casting was also not yet finalized for the film). Instead,The Greatest Showman embraces every convention of the genre and celebrates it with a megawatt smile and a kickline. Jordan explains that he originally recorded demo versions of all of Hugh Jackman's songs from the film, as he had a relationship with songwriters Benj Pasek and Justin Paul. The movie succeeded on word of mouth and repeat viewership in a way that few movies actually do. Barnum, attempting to dispel the obvious hoax. Read More: BROADWAYS KEALA SETTLE TALKS ABOUT SINGING GREATEST SHOWMANS ANTHEM THIS IS ME. What happened Jeremy Jordon? - BIO-Answers.com During the climax of the movie, Barnum's wife, Charity, leaves him when he returns from his truncated tour with Jenny Lind because she sees a newspaper picture of Barnum and Jenny kissing, and also because he mortgaged their house and gambled the entire circus on the tour that got cut short, which means they're now bankrupt. In the end, it took a whopping nine years to makeThe Greatest Showman. Radio Times - February 1117 2023 | PDF - Scribd So, instead of following that annoying theory Just dont want the job. Barnum, perhaps the greatest disservice is done to Jenny Lind, the Swedish opera singer who partnered with Barnum on a tour of America. It does not store any personal data. Answer (1 of 4): The only actors to my knowledge who had their singing dubbed in The Greatest Showman are Rebecca Ferguson as Jenny Lind (who sang "Never Enough" on set but was replaced in post-production by Loren Allred due to the fact that Jenny Lind was meant to be considered the greatest oper. Well, turns out, no one entered the apartment. Plus, why Marc Shaiman roasted Seth's jokes and what Seth really thought of A Beautiful Noise.